Words: Hannah McCormack
In December 2012, The 1975 played the Oh Yeah Music Centre in Belfast to a room of under 100 people. Last year, they headlined Glastonbury to a field of an estimated 100,000 people. Back in 2012 they were a band from Manchester who hadn’t released their first album and the stage of a grassroots music venue in Belfast gave them a space to be seen.
Everyone, including your favourite band, had to start somewhere. However a post-pandemic trend of last minute bookings has emerged for local shows putting artists, promoters and venues at risk. In Belfast, grassroots venues are feeling the impact the most.
Belfast’s beloved bar and music venue Auntie Annie’s closed its doors in 2013 after a period of administration, during which no buyers came forward. The venue had seen the likes of Duke Special and Glen Hansard perform there since opening in 1999 and became a cornerstone of Northern Ireland’s music scene.
The Mandela Hall was demolished by Queen’s University in 2018 to make way for a new Student Centre, despite a rallying petition by its student body to stop such a move. Mandela was home to decade-long live music night Radar, which championed the best Northern Ireland had to offer. Its aim was to consistently platform local artists. Now nearly a decade on, the iconic night is over and the walls that contained it long gone.
Between July 2024 and 2025, 30 grassroots music venues across the UK closed their doors permanently. While this is the lowest decline since 2018, most remaining venues don’t make a profit. The Music Venue Trust published their annual report for 2025 in January of this year. For the first time, it included separate data for grassroots music venues in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in addition to the UK wide data. The report claimed that ‘53.8% of Grassroots Music Venues reported no profit in the last 12 months. Across the whole sector, the average profit margin remained critically low at just 2.5%’. Venues are hanging on, but at what cost?
A lack of advance bookings creates a chain of uncertainty. Venues will look to presale data to determine the need for bar staff, security and whether or not they will make a profit.
Damien McAdams, founder of Radar and current operations director at the Oh Yeah Music Centre spoke of how the trend of people buying last minute feels at venue level, “We’ve suffered from empty venues, cancelled shows and empty weekend nights. It’s not just the uncertainty around the income from the sales that hurts but all the other things that go with it.”
“We’ve suffered from empty venues, cancelled shows and empty weekend nights. It’s not just the uncertainty around the income from the sales that hurts but all the other things that go with it.”
“It is incredibly challenging when looking at the logistics of venue operations, from staffing the bar, stocking the bar, to security numbers etc, which all have a significant financial impact on the viability of shows at this level,” he went on. “The margins that we operate on are extremely tight and getting any one of those things wrong can induce a financial headache. Do that on one show and it can be recouped but having to do that two, three, four times a week and it becomes dangerous.”
“The margins that we operate on are extremely tight and getting any one of those things wrong can induce a financial headache.”
Promoters cannot determine if a gig will go ahead or if an artist will be allowed to play if they need to rely on last minute or even on the night sales. When a bigger touring artist announces a local show, booking is essential months and sometimes even a year in advance. Why the rush? Because these shows are sure to sell out and we are sure to miss out. When it comes to a small artist, leaving it to the last minute becomes an option as that show selling out is less of a possibility. This mentality is a difficult position for local shows to overcome.
For Michael Smyth, founder of Belfast based Old Crows Promotions, this excuse to not buy early is something he keeps hearing, “The answer I hear the most when asking people why they don’t buy pre-sale (tickets) is ‘I know it won’t sell out so I’ll wait and see what I’m doing that weekend’. It feels as though someone sent round a memo that we were all excluded from that simply read ‘no one buy pre-sales anymore’. It feels that drastic.”
“The answer I hear the most when asking people why they don’t buy pre-sale (tickets) is ‘I know it won’t sell out so I’ll wait and see what I’m doing that weekend’.
Michael has put on shows all over Ireland, Northern Ireland and the UK working with bands from the US, Canada, Australia and the EU. He is also a musician with bands Silk and Broncos. For him, the show must always go on, “I operate that it’ll be fine on the night; the show will be good and worthwhile because people got to play and hopefully gain some fans. If you applied this model to any other business, it would be a failure.”
thrive, the research and evaluation people for arts and heritage, reported in 2023 that this trend of last minute booking developed during the pandemic. It seems to have stuck, with 40% of people surveyed reporting that they are still booking more last minute than they used to, according to the Audience Agency Cultural Monitor Report. thrive also reported that those least affected by the cost-of-living crisis are most likely to prebook.
For Chelsea Andrews, front person of Belfast based grunge band GUSH, the effects of this are felt even in rehearsal, “We had a show cancelled not long ago due to lack of advance sales. We were in the middle of our last band practice before the show when the message came through and it was just really deflating. It worries me to see these shows so undervalued as so much work goes into them from everyone involved. We really wanted to play that gig!”
Chelsea is also a promoter, having founded Girls with Guts, which aims to promote and inspire gender diversity within Northern Ireland’s punk and metal scene. The uncertainty has caused her to reflect on whether or not this is worth it, “I really do feel that if it keeps continuing this way, and definitely if it gets any worse, we will end up seeing less grassroots promoters putting on shows. To be honest, it’s why I’ve taken a step back from running Girls with Guts shows. You have to be so confident that who you’re booking is going to shift tickets that every show feels like such a risk.”
This riskiness seems to be felt island wide, with Dundalk music and arts festival Fuineamhh taking to social media to implore buyers to pick up their tickets early. The video, shared to Instagram in April, amassed over 30,000 views, with a subsequent video asking ‘Have you got your tickets sorted?” surpassing 250,000 views.
Michael has also spoken out on Old Crows socials about the importance of buying presale tickets. Michael runs the shoegaze festival Gazefest every August in both Belfast and Dublin. In a post shared recently, he talked about the financial loss putting on a show like that incurs and cited that the future of the festival is dependent on the success of this year.
Grassroots music venues are an important stepping stone to opportunities. Last minute bookings create an uneven terrain that could remove that step in an artist’s journey, remove jobs in the grassroots sector and remove venues altogether. If all doors are closed, where does an artist cut their teeth? Artists need physical spaces to play. Promoters need to feel safe to put on shows. Venues need to keep their doors open. If you kill the grassroots music scene, you kill the entire music scene.